Grinding on takeoff

diesel dually

SDD Junior Member
Joined
Oct 20, 2007
Messages
2
Reaction score
0
Location
newark, DE
I have a 2000 f350 dually with the 6 speed manual transmission and am growing concerned about a grinding noise. The clutch is still strong and a few mechanins said it was fine but I keep worrying about it. It only happens when taking offf from a complete stop and happens right when the clutch is released. Is doenst occur at any other tima nad the other gears are fine and the truck shifts smoothly. Is this normal? Any idea what is causing the sound?
 

PStroked444

SDD Junior Member
Joined
Jul 23, 2008
Messages
23
Reaction score
0
Location
FL-Leesburge
Yes the tranny normaly growles. Search for the thread titled "grinding at low rpm on takeoff". Your question was answered there.:D:cool:
 

Hoss 350

My GSP, Dutch
Joined
Sep 8, 2005
Messages
883
Reaction score
1
Location
Spokane, WA
I have a 2000 f350 dually with the 6 speed manual transmission and am growing concerned about a grinding noise. The clutch is still strong and a few mechanins said it was fine but I keep worrying about it. It only happens when taking offf from a complete stop and happens right when the clutch is released. Is doenst occur at any other tima nad the other gears are fine and the truck shifts smoothly. Is this normal? Any idea what is causing the sound?

It's called "gear rollover" and it is totally normal. I'll try to explain it as best I can.

It is pretty common knowledge that a diesel engine typically makes more horsepower/torque at lower RPMs than a gasoline engine. My diesel pulls as hard at 1500 RPM as my old gasser did at 2500 to 3000. What this means is that each power stroke, in and of itself, must create a lot more power in a diesel than in a gasser, because there are half as many power strokes at half the RPMS, making the same power.

What this means is that the power output of a diesel engine is not very smooth. The rotational force at the crankshaft has 4 pretty impressive surges per revolution. That is one of the major reasons why transmissions that will live for 200K miles behind a big block gasser will croak after 30K on an oil burner (which Dodge and Ford found out the hard way, and caused Chevy to te-think the 4l80E coupling tot he Duramax in 2001). The quick succession of fast, powerful surges at lower RPMS creates a sort of vibration in the transmission, causing the gears to "chatter" against one another, thusly creating the noise you are hearing. You don't hear it at higher RPMS because the time between the surges reduces, and the chatter smooths out. Also, under less load conditions, the surges aren't powerful enough to cause the chatter, so it goes away.

The old-style OBS trucks with the ZF-5 had a dual mass flywheel to try and smooth these surges out, and let the ZF-5 live a bit longer. The newer Super-Duty trucks have a ZF-6 transmission, built, designed, and packaged to live their entire 500,000 mile life coupled to big, medium duty diesel engines liek the one's in our trucks, only on trucks weighing one hell of a lot more than our trucks do. What that means is that your truck will be old, rusted, and busted before you need to worry about your ZF-6 going south on you, as long as you take care of it.

That being said, the gear chatter (rollover) noise gets worse as your transmission fluid ages. If she is pretty loud right now, and you haven't changed the juice in a while, you might consider changing it out soon. I used a full-synthetic ATF and it really quieted it down.

So, in summary, take care of your transmission. Change your fluid every 30 to 50K, and quit worrying!
 

strokin'_tatsch

death row inmate #7
Joined
Jan 13, 2007
Messages
459
Reaction score
0
Location
Austin, Texas
hahahaha... that's basically what i was just told on the phone by Dan vallance from val-air clutch the other day when i asked him why my tranny is grinding like crazy at idle without the clutch pushed in. LoL. he told me to add an extra quart of fluid in it and it should quit. mine does it at idle and when i'm slowing down and leave it in gear til it gets down to around 1000 rpms. apparently mine does it so bad b/c it doesn't idle as smooth as it should
 

xtrahappy

SDD Junior Member
Joined
Feb 5, 2009
Messages
23
Reaction score
0
Location
florence, mississippi
I bought same type truck. It made lil bit of noise, not much. Clutch started slipping in high gears. Well I replaced clutch, and mines growls on take-offs and when holding back ( slowing down). Changed oil, still really loud. The clutch kit (flywheel & all) came from local parts house. It seems to work ok, I pull heavy loads at times. BUT IT MAKES HECK OF ALOT NOISE.
 

Members online

Forum statistics

Threads
30,517
Messages
266,070
Members
14,629
Latest member
Colvinecoboost14
Top